In West Bank, Israeli And Palestinian Archaeologists Both Lay Claim To Heritage

Feb 16, 2017
Originally published on February 16, 2017 9:29 am

If history is a matter of dispute in the Middle East, so too is some of the archaeology underway to document and preserve remnants of that history.

The Israeli military has an archaeology unit that is responsible for excavations in most of the West Bank, land captured by Israel in 1967 and sought by Palestinians for an independent state.

According to an Israeli-Palestinian agreement, the status of the West Bank — and the artifacts found there — are to be negotiated in eventual peace talks. Until then, the military archaeologists continue to dig — and grant excavation permits to Israeli academics to dig — in the West Bank.

"Our work is mainly to preserve the history of the area," said Benny Har-Even, the military's deputy staff officer for archaeology, walking among the ruins of a village dating to the 2nd century B.C.

Nearby, the Palestinian workers the army employs laid cement to reinforce a row of stones, preparing the site as a tourist destination.

The military's archaeologists see their job as a race to save some 3,000 known archeological sites in the area. "We need to take care of them, to protect them, to try to avoid bandits destroying them," Har-Even said.

But some aspects of Israeli archaeology in West Bank are not made public by the army, according to Israeli archaeologist Rafi Greenberg of Emek Shaveh, a left-wing group of archaeologists critical of the digging.

"They do not publish the list of excavations or the list of excavators or the list of finds or the location of their storerooms," said Greenberg. "That's all kept as a state secret."

The group accuses Israel of using archaeology to strengthen its control of the West Bank, and it sued in court to find out which Israeli academics were granted permits to excavate there, among other information.

An Israeli judge ruled in November that the identity of those archaeologists would remain classified, to protect them from boycotts by colleagues around the world who object to cooperation with Israel's military occupation of the West Bank.

Greenberg believes the secrecy speaks volumes.

"If it's wrong, then don't do it. And if it's right, tell everybody about it," he said. "But this approach that we are not going to let on, it raises suspicions. What can you say? If someone is not going to be transparent, they've got something to hide."

In an interview, one archaeologist from an Israeli university who excavates in the West Bank, and who has published many books about his finds, asked not to be identified out of fear that drawing attention could lead to being boycotted.

"I don't think I am doing something wrong," the archaeologist said. "I think I am salvaging data."

The army's archaeologists say their work is necessary to protect important historical finds from being lost to a thriving market of Palestinian antiquities thieves. But former Palestinian Authority antiquities chief Hamdan Taha believes Israeli archaeologists are the ones behaving like antiquities thieves, digging in occupied land under a cloak of anonymity.

"It provides a legal framework for open looting," Taha said. "It is turning the role of archaeology from scientific recovery of the past to [a] treasure hunt."

Army archaeologists keep the artifacts they find in designated storerooms, and occasionally lend them to museums and research institutes for display. The Israeli court ruled in November that it would not reveal the location of the storerooms. It also ruled it would not reveal which artifacts were on display nor identify the institutions displaying them, following Israeli government concerns that publishing the information could hurt Israel's foreign relations and affect future negotiations with the Palestinians, among other reasons.

Palestinian Authority archaeologists do conduct their own digs in areas of the West Bank they govern, and collaborate with international colleagues, but they don't conduct joint digs with the Israeli military. The Palestinians who work for Israel's military archaeologists are laborers unaffiliated with the Palestinian government.

Some Israeli archaeologists argue they provide an important service in the West Bank because excavations could not be carried out in the same professional manner by Palestinian archaeologists, who they say are not as qualified. Taha rejects that argument.

"This is a cheap argument, and I don't want to respond to this, because this is exactly the mentality of occupier: dominance," he said.

Taha does acknowledge problems: Some historical buildings have been demolished by private Palestinian contractors to make way for new structures in the West Bank, which Taha blames on an outdated Palestinian law that does not adequately protect cultural heritage sites. And the field of Palestinian archaeology studies at West Bank academic institutions is young and developing. The Palestinian Authority still hasn't replaced Taha since he retired from his position as antiquities chief in 2014.

Still, he said, even during times of violence, Palestinians have not let archaeological sites meet the same fate of sites in Syria and Iraq destroyed by ISIS.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

Somewhere near its heart, the Middle East conflict is a fight over history. Each side has a story to tell about who was first on the land, and each competing view of history becomes part of the argument over who should rule it now. So it's become a sensitive matter that Israel is conducting archaeological digs on the West Bank, land captured by Israel in 1967 and sought by Palestinians for a future state. The archaeology is a military operation and sometimes a secretive one. NPR's Daniel Estrin reports.

(SOUNDBITE OF HAMMERING)

DANIEL ESTRIN, BYLINE: Here's one archaeological site in the West Bank - the ruins of a village from the 2nd century B.C. When I visited on a recent morning, Palestinian workers were laying cement to reinforce a row of stones. They're working for the Israeli military. Benny Har-Even is the Israeli military's deputy archaeologist.

BENNY HAR-EVEN: Our work is mainly to preserve the history of the area.

ESTRIN: The Israeli military is in charge of archaeology in most of the West Bank. The military archeologists see their job as a race to save history.

HAR-EVEN: We have 3,000 archaeologic site that we know of, and we need to take care of them, to protect them, to try to avoid bandits of destroying them. So we are a professional person.

ESTRIN: The status of the West Bank and the artifacts found there is supposed to be negotiated in peace talks. Until then, military archaeologists and Israeli academics continue to dig in the West Bank. But some of what they do there is not made public by the army, according to Israeli archaeologist Rafi Greenberg. He's part of a left-wing group of archaeologists critical of the digging.

RAFI GREENBERG: So they do not publish the list of excavations or the list of excavators or the list of finds or the location of their storeroom. That's all kept as a state secret.

ESTRIN: His group accuses Israel of using the digs to strengthen its control of the West Bank. The group sued in court to find out which Israeli academics were excavating there. The Israeli judge said that information would remain classified to protect archaeologists from boycotts by colleagues around the world. Greenberg says the secrecy speaks volumes.

GREENBERG: If it's wrong, then don't do it. And if it's right, then tell everybody about it.

ESTRIN: The army archaeologists say they prevent important finds from being lost to a thriving market of Palestinian antiquities thieves. Former Palestinian antiquities chief Hamdan Taha says Israeli archaeologists are the ones who are acting like antiquities thieves, digging in occupied land under a cloak of anonymity.

HAMDAN TAHA: It provides a legal framework for open looting. It is turning the role of archaeology from scientific recovery of the past to treasure hunt.

ESTRIN: Palestinian archaeologists do conduct their own digs and collaborate with international archaeologists, but they don't cooperate with the Israeli military. Taha rejects an Israeli argument that Palestinian archaeologists are not as qualified as their Israeli counterparts.

TAHA: This is a cheap argument, and I don't want to respond to this because this is exactly the mentality of occupier - dominance.

ESTRIN: Taha does acknowledge problems. Some historical buildings have been demolished by Palestinians in the West Bank, and Palestinian archaeology is a young field. And the Palestinian Authority still hasn't replaced him since he retired in 2014. But he says even during times of violence, Palestinians didn't let archaeological sites meet the same fate as sites in Syria and Iraq destroyed by ISIS. Daniel Estrin, NPR News, the West Bank. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.