© 2026 WKNO FM
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate

After a floor debate last week, Tennessee's legislature gave the final sign-off and became the fifth state to call for a constitional convention.
Stephen Jerkins
After a floor debate last week, Tennessee's legislature gave the final sign-off and became the fifth state to call for a constitional convention.

WPLN's Chas Sisk explains to host Blake Farmer what it would take for a constitutional convention to really happen and where the movement originated.

Last week, Tennessee became the fifth state where lawmakers voted to open up the country’s founding documents and make a few tweaks or go even further. Here's the audio that helps explain what's going on:

State Rep. Sheila Butt, R-Columbia, has pushed the call through the Tennessee House of Representatives. Here's why she believes a new constitutional convention is necessary:

Hear state Rep. Sheila Butt argue for a constitutional convention.

The idea has been put forward by conservative and tea party activists. That has led many Democrats to fear that minority groups would be underrepresented at a constitutional convention.

State Rep. Johnny Shaw, D-Bolivar, says he doesn't believe the federal government has overreached. In fact, he argues, it's done a better job than the states of protecting the rights of African-Americans.

Here he is going toe-to-toe with Butt.

Hear Reps. Butt and Shaw debate whether a constitutional convention can be "trusted" to protect minority rights.

The skeptics include some Republicans. State Rep. Terri Lynn Weaver, R-Lancaster, says Tennessee will have no control over what would happen once a convention begins.

Hear why Rep. Terri Lynn Weaver believes a constitutional convention is "the ultimate Trojan horse."

Making a similar argument, Rep. Rick Womick, R-Rockvale, notes that delegates from Democratic states like California, New York and Colorado will have just as much power to propose amendments as those sent from Republican-led states.

Hear Rep. Rick Womick argue why he doesn't think a constitutional convention can be trusted.

Even supporters of a constitutional convention admit it would be a major step.

In the most headline-grabbing statements of the debate, state Rep. Judd Matheny, R-Tullahoma, compares it to the threat of a nuclear weapon. He says simply deploying it would force Congress to act on his side's proposals, like a balanced budget amendment and term limits.

Hear Rep. Judd Matheny describe why he supports deploying the "atomic bomb of politics."

Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate
Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate
Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate
Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate
Five Quotes That Help Explain Tennessee's Constitutional Convention Debate

Copyright 2016 WPLN News

Chas joined WPLN in 2015 after eight years with The Tennessean, including more than five years as the newspaper's statehouse reporter.Chas has also covered communities, politics and business in Massachusetts and Washington, D.C. Chas grew up in South Carolina and attended Columbia University in New York, where he studied economics and journalism. Outside of work, he's a dedicated distance runner, having completed a dozen marathons